It is no surprise to any regular reader of this blog that we’re having a baby. Well, more to the point, my wife is. I am cheerleading. It will also come as no surprise to regular readers that we are interested in minimizing our babies exposure to the toxic chemicals regularly contained in many of the daily-use products required for raising a baby. For example, our crib has a non-toxic finish, and our bamboo flooring in non-gassing.
As the baby could come anytime now, we’ve spent some considerable time this week looking into cloth diapers. I know there are studies saying not to use cloth for environmental reasons — this one, for example. I won’t get into the whole debate – others have done much of that! Instead, I’ll share with you what I’ve found in my research, and what we’ve decided to do for now…
If you are set on using disposables, there is good news — you can still do so without having such a negative environmental impact. Check out Nature Care Diapers, disposables that are compostible, and made from GM-free corn – not plastic! Another option is the Seventh Generation diapers, which are also chemical-free, but not compostable. The gDiaper is marketed as an option for mothers not willing to commit to cloth, but looking to drop a smaller load in the garbage can (or toilet): they have a compostible insert that can be flushed. However, they may be too good to be true – the city of Vancouver completed a study on the impact of flushing the insert after the gDiaper was released in North America. Also, the liners contain some of the same harsh chemicals as plastic-based disposables (and if I could find the site I found the other day, I’d link to it!) If that doesn’t turn you off, consider that the cost of the liners (around 40 cents each) is the same as a Seventh Generation diaper, and is almost 5 cents more expensive than the Nature Care. As such, we have some Nature Care disposables on hand for when we are going out, however, we are going to try to use cloth.
Before deciding what to buy (and try) we consulted with my mother (who used cloth just 29 years ago on me), my sister (who started using cloth a couple years ago, and will start all over again in a couple months) and my sister-in-law (who is using cloth right now.) We took everything they said, processed it, threw it out, considered it again, threw it out again, and then decided what to do.
We considered pre-folds – these are essentially diapers that are an absorbent cotton, hemp, or bamboo liner, that you “prefold” before you put them on the baby, and are held in place by pins (sometimes) and a plasticy, though not always plastic, liner (always). The advantage of pre-folds is that they dry very quickly, and are less expensive than other cloth diapers to purchase. As we investigated, we found that if you buy organic prefolds, they aren’t all that cheap – around $10 each – compared to non-organic, which can be as cheap as $1.50 or $2.00 each. This brings the cost of using them up substantially, as over the non-potty-trained years a child will require 3 sizes of prefolds (though I read that the smaller prefolds make great dishcloths when they no longer fit…)
The complete opposite of the prefold is the “all-in-one” – this is essentially a cloth diaper that you use like a disposable, except for the whole “dispose” part. It is a multi-layered cloth diaper that goes on like a disposable, and the whole thing gets thrown into the wash after being used (and after the parent scrapes the doo doo off, of course.) We considered the Bum Genius Organic (these diapers come with great names) — however, with a diaper of this girth (it is also a one-size diaper – more on that later) to launder and dry the entire thing every poo poo or pee pee would consume a lot of energy and water. My sister-in-law noted that the all-in-ones she bought took a long time to dry. In terms of cost, this option would be more than pre-folds to start, as well as launder.
The middle-ground of these two types is the pocket diaper — this is similar to an all-in-one, but has a removable pad that takes the brunt of your baby’s gastrointestinal force, and is removed to launder, allowing it to dry more quickly. Swaddlebess has a partially-organic pocket diaper that we inherited a few of — however, when looking into the cost of small, mediums, and larges, we were a bit taken aback.
At this point, we went back and considered the prefolds again – we were given a couple of those, as well. In the end, we ordered some of the Econappi, which is a pocket diaper with an insert that can also have an additional layer of absorbency added in on top (like you would with a prefold). Also, it is a one-size diaper (like the Bum Genius) which means that the size of the diaper can be adjusted using snaps — both claim to work for babies from 7 to 35 pounds (we’ll see, I suppose…) We figure the Econappi is a good compromise, and will give it, along with our inherited and gifted diapers, a try. Worst case scenario, we buy something different. Stay tuned for more of the messy details!